In early July of 2016, I recorded Hermit Thrushes and White-throated Sparrows singing at first light at Spring Pond Bog, a Nature Conservancy Preserve located in the Adirondack Mountains in northern New York. I was disappointed with the recording for reasons I will explain later, and I almost threw it away. But upon further examination several days ago (almost exactly seven years later), I was shocked to discover that I had actually captured a soundscape worthy of considerable admiration and praise.
So … without further ado … please listen to the following, which is my well-meaning attempt at affecting an alchemical transformation of my original field recording from base metal to gold, with the aim of distilling the “Celestial Music” perhaps contained therein. Note that this rendition has been pitch-lowered about an octave to appeal more to our human musical sensibilities, but otherwise it is an entirely natural earth-expression, with no layering of multiple recordings to densify the soundscape.
Note: The recordings featured below are “3D binaural soundscapes”. Please wear headphones or earbuds for a spacious and immersive listening experience. And if you’re using Apple AirPods, be sure to disable spatial audio processing.
Dawn chorus at Spring Pond Bog – This rendition has been pitch-lowered by nearly an octave, to bring the bird songs into a frequency range more palatable to the human ear. Please listen using headphones!
The Backstory:
You may wonder why I almost threw away this recording. Well, I was upset because a fairly stiff wind blew-in just before dawn and created a high level of constant “whoosh,” caused by the wind blowing through tall pines and spruces on a ridge at the edge of the bog. I found this upsetting because I had desired and expected pristine light-wind conditions. So, when I listened to the recording later in the day, I was immediately disappointed and decided it was more-or-less of little use, especially given that I have much “cleaner” dawn chorus recordings from earlier visits to the same bog. Here is an excerpt from my original whooshy recording:
Here is a sample of my raw, unaltered dawn chorus recording made at Spring Pond Bog on 3 July 2016. The strong “whoosh” is due to wind blowing through tall pines and spruces on a nearby ridge. Please listen using headphones.
The more I listened, the more impressed I became. My previous dawn choruses from the same location are more diverse in composition, and not so pleasing from a purely musical standpoint. So, in an attempt to clarify the bird songs, I excitedly applied some “broadband noise reduction” using state-of-the-art sound editing software, with the goal of reducing the sound of the wind without compromising the bird songs. To my delight, the result sounds pretty darned good. The wind whoosh has been reduced but not eliminated, and the bird songs are undistorted, at least to my ears.
A whoosh-reduced version of the above recording, made in hopes of clarifying the bird songs for greater human appreciation of the inherent “musicality” of the mix. Please listen using headphones!
The whoosh-reduced version of the recording has now been pitch-lowered by nearly an octave, to bring the bird songs into a frequency range more palatable to the human ear. Please listen using headphones!
ethereal melodies, celestial music,
springing forth from the damp, musty bog,
funneled through the throats of birds …
music from the heavens, elixir to one’s ears?
Coda:
Sometimes I discover beauty hiding right under my nose, sound recordings I’ve made that don’t impress me upon first listening, that I inadvertently label as “defective,” when in reality they are brightly-shining jewels. Obscured by some perceived flaw, I may not perceive their brilliance until years later, when I stumble upon them again and listen with a more experienced ear, with a more mature and all-encompassing sense of what is beautiful. My recording from Spring Pond Bog is a prime example.
Now, as I listen to the examples featured above and ponder this matter further, I can’t help but conclude that the whooshy original is actually better in most respects than my various precipitations. By denying the wind as a supportive actor in the soundscape, I rejected the concert as Mother Earth produced it, on that special morning in that special place. How imperceptive of me, and how demeaning to natural world! The original recording embodies the most accurate living representation of the flow of sound during that particular passage of time. So who am I to think it is somehow defective, in need of reshaping by my own hand?
While my distillations are certainly instructive, it seems most important for me to hone my senses as well as my entire outlook and disposition to more fully receive, accept and “feel” the full import of what nature offers, of “what is” rather than “what I would like to be”. I am humbled and I regret that my desire for a calm morning on the third of July in 2016 clouded my senses and my mind, and distracted me from sinking into the magic of the moment while I was actually there at Spring Pond Bog, walking, wading, swimming in the breezy miracle of creation.
So, once again … enjoy my original field recording, wind and bird songs uncensored, a creative interplay between the Earth and the Heavens … Celestial Music enlivening the boggy wilds, untouched by the human hand:
Once again, here is my raw, unaltered dawn chorus (with wind), captured at Spring Pond Bog … this is the “real thing,” just as it occurred in nature. Please listen using headphones.
Naturally Yours,
Friends … if you find that my blog posts and other media featured on this website have a positive impact on your life, please help support my effort by making a modest donation.
Hello Everyone! Would you like to see a photo of yourself (or any other graphic) next to your comment? I sure would like to see lots of happy faces. So please Go Here to learn how.
Hi Lang,
I’m of no use helping you choose. I typically would prefer recording nature as nature, whoosh and all but upon listening to both, i would chose either. I say do both
Thanks for the deeper exploration of the experience, Lang. I agree wholeheartedly that we can miss beauty given freely from Nature by having our own ‘preference’ in the way. How very human of us! And, so happy you found this anew. I love both of the mixes.
Think the original is my favorite but they all are beautiful! Thank you!
: >)
The “whoosh” sounds like a waterfall! The lowered pitch sounds like musical instruments, like a flute and a piccolo. I like all three, and all three, in my work, would have different applications. So all of the variations are useful.
Yes, agreed. While most commenters prefer the original, I definitely think there is a place for the altered version in the grand scheme of things.
I loved the original windy version right away ~ no need to reduce or alter in any way. The wind gives it ‘place’…..It’s funny when we think we can ‘do better than nature’, and it’s nice to know we can experiment, be playful and appreciate what is, as you so nicely expressed. Yes, the natural one sounds best and feels the best in my body.
I agree that while the modified versions are interesting and fascinating, I ultimately prefer the original recording, breeze and all. Makes me feel like I’m sitting there knowing we can’t control nature and enjoying whatever we get! Thanks for another awesome blog!
I love the original as I love the forest as is with no mis takes to it
I like the original- There is something special about things that are just as is in the moment. I like to find extraordinary in the ordinary.
OMG that lower pitched version is amazing!
Yes, it is amazing, to put it lightly.
I like all three of them because they are each unique.
I only listened to the first recording but it brought tears to my eyes. The hermit thrush has my very favorite song and I first heard it in Rustler Park, in the Chiricahua Mountains. Is there a way I can purchase or download it? It’s truly heavenly.
Karen: Please contact me via my email: langelliott@mac.com
Hello Everyone! Would you like to see a photo of yourself (or any other graphic) next to your comment? I sure would like to see lots of happy faces. So please Go Here to learn how.
Ethereal! Two beautiful voices entwined.
Your different versions remind me of the way different conductors interpret a musical piece. All are relevant, just a different point of view.
Agreed!
AMAAAAAZING! Thanks so much for not having thrown it away and for giving it a second chance! I’ve always thought the hermit thrush song was otherworldly, but joined together with the earnest clarion tones of the white throats — it amounts to the closest I’ve ever heard of what I’ve only imagined the Music of the Spheres might be!
Yes … “Music of the Spheres” … I almost threw that phrase into my discussion, in the being of Hazrat Inyat Kahn, if you’ve heard of him.
Hi Lang: (Peter typing – we briefly met at the headquarters building at Seany NWR in May of ’88 as you & Ted Mack were considering giving up on getting good Yellow Rail recordings) I agree w/you that the original version is the best for pure enjoyment & the others have value for other reasons. Sound is so lovely. And it’s interesting on how our outlooks change with time. Say hello to Ted & fellow recordist Sean O’Brien (? I think was his name) if they are still around. We birded the Niagara Falls area one late fall ~25 years… Read more »
Hi there Peter. Wow, 1988, that was the year I did my first major recording expedition, with none other than Ted Mack! I well remember our challenge to get Yellow Rail, and we had moderate success. I’m actually heading up to the Adirondacks tomorrow and will visit Ted, who unfortunately is ailing from lung cancer (more accurately, he’s ailing from the aggressive treatment of it, which destroyed one lung). He’s in his 80s now and I’m not far behind.
One of my favorite birds songs is that of the Hermit Thrush. I frequently hear them throughout the higher elevations in Monongahela National Forest here in West Virginia. I love the different perspective the octave down version gives. I am not sure if I could pick a favorite though. They are all beautiful in their own right. Thanks for sharing your work with the world!
Thank you Ben. I think I rest in the middle, as you do, appreciating both versions for what they represent.
Love the original too…wonderful to hear so many together…I didn’t even hear one Hermit Thrush at my place in NEPA this year.
I prefer the original version. As I heard the wind whoosh at the beginning, I whispered “wow…” It reminded me of the ephemeral nature of what you were hearing and recording in that place. Exquisitely beautiful. The pure tones, all interwoven, spiraling, echoing. Never to be repeated. Sacred. Thank you for sharing it.
Well-chosen words … “Exquisitely beautiful. The pure tones, all interwoven, spiraling, echoing.”
Lang, To my ears, your post-processed version sounds the best as I am most able to follow along with the melody or melodies and to pick out individual voices and components of the whole, without the background whoosh. I also get a better sense of the spatial arrangement. As to whether there is a level of integration among the thrushes – absolutely! It sounds to me that the entire chorus is choreographed – the result of thousands of years of evolution. How the post-processing affects these interpretations is a question worthy of study, but there is quite a lot going… Read more »
Finally … someone votes for the pitch-lowered version! I am relieved. I actually like them both, for different reasons of course.
The original version definitely gets my vote. It is natural, and it is uplifting. I found the pitch-lowered distillation rather eerie and actually a little depressing, oddly enough! The original recording is marvelous. Thanks for sharing.
Thank you Luane!
I actually prefer the original “whooshy” recording to a significant degree. It sounds like wind in the pines to me, and adds another dimension of “being there-ness” to the sounds. I also really prefer listening to the hermit thrush at its original pitch, but I do recognize that might be difficult for some folks (and me probably in 20 years or so). Thank you for not throwing anything away! Like all creative endeavors, it benefitted from re-thinking after some time had passed.
Looks like the whooshy original is on its way to winning the race! But I guess we should wait and see what others say before actually awarding the medal.
I really like the original version with the wind sounds, for the reasons you mention — to me it captures the actual experience of being there, which is immersive and engaging and lovely. Thank you for posting! I have had many similar experiences with my music compositions and recordings, of not “liking” a piece initially because of various flaws I can perceive vs what I hoped for/intended/my ideal, but then later (sometimes years later) finally hearing its charm and presence. Plus, I think I’ve mentioned this before, but various weather/environmental conditions can change what we hear — so I have… Read more »
I definitely like the wind, though I wish it were “moving” around a bit to add some dynamic to its space. On that morning, there was a moderate constant breeze blowing through the pines (and some spruces) on an esker that rises up on one side of the boggy area in which I recorded. That’s why the wind is to one side and more or less constant and unvarying.
I’m actually heading back up to Spring Pond Bog tomorrow.
The slowed down version is great! It takes me to another world and shows just how intricate these songs really are. It sounds as if there’s a kind of phrasing going on, where each bird is considering where to place its next strophe, or is that just me imposing a human “poetic” sensibility? Anyway, Hermit Thrushes seem to encourage artistic license – I remember your Hermit Thrush ringtone! But I really like the original recording, as it places the birdsong in context, even though the wind is a little monotonous. And I hear a frog, too, which adds to the picture in… Read more »
Martin: Thank you for your thoughtful comments. I’m surprised you found my post because I haven’t put out the word yet, given that I’m still tweaking it. I’m impressed that you noticed the muted sounds of the frogs in the background; most listeners will probably miss them entirely. They are Green Frogs, calling from a pool that is quite a distance away, in the middle of the open bog. I actually plan to visit Spring Pond Bog in a couple of days and one of my main projects is to hike across the rather enormous bog and record the frogs… Read more »
As it’s the post-solstice turning of the year, just by chance I thought, “I wonder if Lang has posted anything recently?” So I checked, and you had! Maybe nature lovers are connected through the collective subconscious… Good luck with recording at the pool & please don’t disappear!
Yes, please don’t disappear into the bog, Lang!!!